Here’s an interesting problem:
Jay Z’s “The Blueprint, Pt. 3″ is the hot album of the fall. The duet with Alicia Keys, “Empire State of Mind,” is the single of the season. Neither of them is eligible for the Grammy Awards.
Let’s backtrack: this year’s Grammy deadline was August 31st, a month early. The Jay Z album was not released until September 8th.
But we knew going in that the early Grammy deadline was crazy. Whitney Houston just made it under the wire. But Mariah Carey missed it, leaving her in the mix just for her “Obsessed” single.
At this rate, whatever gets nominated for Best Album, Record, and Song is a toss up, and not a popular one.
The odds on favorite would be The Black Eyed Peas album, “The E.N.D.” The single, “I Gotta Feeling,” is the odds on favorite for Best Record and Song.
There are scant others. Lady GaGa is headed into the Amy Winehouse section as novelty hit of the year. You can’t begrudge her anything, but she has the feel of a one-hit wonder.
There’s a lot of support for rock band Kings of Leon, too. But they may wind up in the rock categories.
Other possibilities: Kanye West’s “808s and Heartbreak,” U2’s “No Line on the Horizon,” Bruce Springsteen’s “Working on a Dream,” Rob Thomas’s excellent “CradleSong” (with the song “Someday”), and, of course, Whitney Houston’s “I Look to You.” Houston is likely to score well in the Grammys simply because it’s a slow year.
But the absence of Jay Z and Alicia? Immeasurable impact. Especially since the bogus American Music Awards — in which everything is eligible including Michael Jackson’s greatest hits — lets anything go as long as there are ratings and sponsors.
Meantime, I do hope the Grammy committees are aware that Stevie Wonder had a great single out in January, called “All About the Love Again.” It was included on the inauguration soundtrack. What a shame if it’s overlooked.
The Grammys have historically always been screwy anyway. Michael Jackson’s “Off the Wall” and Billy Joel’s “The Stranger” were never even nominated. How do you like that? The Beatles always got short shrift too. For example: In 1969-70, “Abbey Road” — now considered one of the great classics of all time — was beaten by Blood Sweat, and Tears’ self titled album. Other nominees were the Fifth Dimension, Johnny Cash, and Crosby, Stills & Nash’s debut LP. Even worse: in 1963, Ray Charles, Tony Bennett, and Stan Getz all lost to Vaughn Meader’s comedy album, “The First Family.”


November 2nd, 2009 at 9:14 am
Excuse me Roger, but…”here are scant others. Lady GaGa is headed into the Amy Winehouse section as novelty hit of the year. You can’t begrudge her anything, but she has the feel of a one-hit wonder.”
Where as AMY WINEHOUSE, did have only One Hit here, “Rehab”, Lady Gaga is already on her 4th # 1 Hit, “Just Dance”. “Pokerface”, “Paparazzi”, and the next which is going to be “Bad Romance” from her forthcoming follow-up CD. So, please explain what you mean by ONE HIT WONDER.
November 2nd, 2009 at 1:26 pm
Good lord, Roger. You’ve been so productive today and yet you’re all wrong. Lady Gaga is the most creative artist in this century and far eclipses Madonna’s considerable career, even at this early stage.
Billy Crystal is a hack and stopped being funny in the 1910s. How about Russell Brand as Oscar host? He’d bring an audience and shake the current one out of its stupor.
And Jacko died a pedophile. Always was, always will be.
November 2nd, 2009 at 1:49 pm
Roger, I don’t see how you can knock those ‘69-70 nominees. The Fifth Dimension’s “Aquarius” was one of the best albums of all time. So it’s not just aboout the Beatles. And how can you crap on CSN’s debut?!
And Lady Gaga’s already had more than one hit so she can’t be a one hit wonder.
I agree “The Stranger” should’ve been nominated. But why don’t you tell us what WERE? Maybe they were all equally deserving too.
December 3rd, 2009 at 7:30 am
[...] and his “All About the Love Again.” It’s a throwaway, but maybe someone read my November 2nd column. Also: two noms for unknown R&B singer Calvin Richardson, on the very small Shanachie [...]